A test we conducted in Wallace Hall
And the lift, how did it enthrall
But flow separation
Caused much aggravation
For the tail did nothing but stall
-
Some background – with only a semester left in my undergraduate career the only thing separating me from graduation is a few measly credit hours…and this trivial experience known as senior design. An experience of discovery if there ever was one: take five clueless college students, add sadistic design requirements, an impossibly short time schedule, and shake well with coffee – the result is (one hopes) an airplane that not only flies but is superior to the work of students from universities all over the world. As one could guess by now, the culmination of the past semester of work, our self-administered “final,” a test of our design did not go quite as planned. In a shocking revelation, the more you know the less you know. Putting technical details aside for a moment however, this is a perfect opportunity to reflect on the value of things going pear-shaped, something that we (or at least I) do far too infrequently. Bizarre as it seems, one should almost be thankful for the times when one’s knowledge and experience falter, for it is these instances which allow us to improve ourselves. The value of being wrong is certainly immediate – we surely won’t make the same mistake again soon – but it also reaches deeper.
When we are confronted by the limits of our knowledge (or what we thought was knowledge), we are forced to take a step back and evaluate what we “know” and why we “know” it. There is certainly a humbling effect when we falter, and our faith in ourselves and our collective understanding of the world can certainly be shaken. While such far-reaching effects are unlikely in such a trivial failure as my group experienced this week, humans face this time and again in our grandest works – bridges fall, societies collapse, and our collective mastery of the world and ourselves is revealed as hubris. Such experiences are uncomfortable - for a species whose survival has long been predicated on our mastery of our surroundings it is naturally frightening. From another perspective however, these events bring us exciting new possibilities. I shudder to imagine a world where we’ve figured everything out – while humans have an insatiable desire to understand our world, we are like dogs chasing cars: if we ever succeeded we’d be purposeless.
Each failure is an opportunity to revolutionize our understanding of our world. There are countless new developments, waiting to change our world forever, simply lacking some gap in our understanding to be remedied or overturned in order to proceed at breakneck pace. We often hear cited the role of serendipity in science – how one lucky thing going just right set off a revolution, but little mentioned is the serendipity of simply being wrong.
Little consolation is this to anyone (especially to those of us facing a problematic tail redesign), but perhaps with some work we can view failing and ignorance, once exposed, as exciting opportunities for improvement. With some thought and effort we may even become thankful for our foibles.


Recent Comments